Judge.me vs Stamped: which should you choose?
Quick answer: Judge.me is built for ecommerce, while Stamped suits ecommerce. For most users Stamped is the stronger default, but Judge.me can be the better fit depending on your budget and use case. Judge.me has the lower entry price.
Both Judge.me and Stamped get recommended a lot, but they solve the job differently. Below we compare them on pricing, strengths and the use cases each one fits, then give a clear verdict.
Side-by-side
| Judge.me | Stamped | |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Reviews Ugc | Reviews Ugc |
| What it's known for | Affordable, fast Shopify reviews app with a strong free tier: photo/video reviews, Q&A, rich snippets and broad adoption, especially among smaller and price-sensitive stores. | Reviews, ratings, UGC and loyalty for e-commerce: photo/video reviews, Q&A, NPS and a loyalty/rewards module, a mid-market Yotpo/Okendo alternative. |
| Pricing | Free plan (most core features); reported ~$15/mo Awesome plan unlocking advanced features; Shopify-focused | No free plan/trial; reported ~$23/mo entry (by order count) up to reported ~$798/mo full bundle for established stores |
| Best audience | Price-sensitive and smaller Shopify stores wanting strong reviews without per-order fees. | Mid-market Shopify brands wanting reviews plus loyalty as a Yotpo/Okendo alternative. |
| Best for | ecommerce, shopify | ecommerce, shopify |
| Entry price | Free | ~$23/mo |
| Biggest strength | Genuinely generous free plan (unlimited reviews, widgets, photo/video, rich snippets). | Native data link between reviews and loyalty (review submission auto-awards points). |
| Main caveat | Advanced features (AI, 130+ integrations, syndication) require the paid Awesome plan. | No free plan or free trial since the 2025 pricing restructure (must commit to a paid plan). |
Features compared
Where they really diverge is in the day-to-day feature set:
Judge.me key features
- Unlimited product reviews, star ratings and photo/video UGC (incl. on free plan)
- Q&A and 16 widgets (snippets, reviews page)
- Automatic Review schema JSON-LD for rich snippets
- AI replies, summaries and translations (Awesome plan)
Stamped key features
- Product reviews, ratings and photo/video UGC
- Q&A
- Built-in NPS surveys
- Loyalty & rewards module with multiple earning triggers
Pricing tiers side by side
Judge.me plans
| Plan | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Forever Free | $0 | Unlimited reviews, widgets, photo/video, rich snippets |
| Awesome | $15/mo | Flat fee; AI, 130+ integrations, syndication, referrals |
Stamped plans
| Plan | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Up to 200 orders | ~$23/mo | Entry, by monthly orders |
| Up to 1,000 orders | ~$99/mo | Reported |
| Up to 5,000 orders | ~$199/mo | Reported |
| 20,000+ orders | Custom (reported to ~$798/mo full bundle) | Quote-based |
Tiers compiled from the vendors' published plans and independent reviews; prices are approximate and change often, so confirm current figures (and your region's taxes) on each vendor's site.
Strengths compared
Where Judge.me wins
An unusually generous free reviews app with a single flat $15/mo upgrade.
- Genuinely generous free plan (unlimited reviews, widgets, photo/video, rich snippets).
- Flat, transparent $15/mo paid tier regardless of store size.
That makes it the stronger pick for price-sensitive and smaller Shopify stores wanting strong reviews without per-order fees.
Where Stamped wins
Reviews-first e-commerce platform with a tightly linked native loyalty module.
- Native data link between reviews and loyalty (review submission auto-awards points).
- Strong in-email review submission experience and Google SEO value.
That makes it the stronger pick for mid-market Shopify brands wanting reviews plus loyalty as a Yotpo/Okendo alternative.
Verdict: choose by fit
Both are good at the job, so let your priorities decide.
- Choose Judge.me if you fit its core audience — price-sensitive and smaller Shopify stores wanting strong reviews without per-order fees.
- Choose Stamped if you fit its core audience — mid-market Shopify brands wanting reviews plus loyalty as a Yotpo/Okendo alternative.
FAQ
Is Judge.me better than Stamped?
Stamped is the stronger default for most users, but Judge.me can be the better fit depending on your budget and use case.
What is the main difference between Judge.me and Stamped?
Judge.me is an unusually generous free reviews app with a single flat $15/mo upgrade. Stamped is reviews-first e-commerce platform with a tightly linked native loyalty module.
Which is cheaper, Judge.me or Stamped?
Entry pricing differs: Judge.me offers a free tier, while Stamped starts at ~$23/mo. Compare the tiers above against your usage.
Sources
Facts above are drawn from these independent reviews and the vendors' own pages for Judge.me and Stamped: